Prince Napoleon’s Views in 1861

Prince Napoleon, nephew of Bonaparte, visited the US during July and August 1861 as the Civil War was beginning. On his trek westward he noted the deep effect German immigration was having in Missouri.

Prince Napoleon’s Views in 1861

“The predominance of the German element in the Army of the West is the result of the nature of the sources which fed the recruitment of volunteers. Many causes forced the Germans to serve the flag. First, the high pay of soldiers, an almost irresistible attraction for wretched emigrants who left their country because of their misfortune, and who, if they found bread in their new motherland, were nonetheless forced to earn it daily with their sweat. Moreover, Germany is the traditional land of professional soldiers. Germans embraced the military profession willingly, and not so long ago, they served as mercenaries in many of the world’s armies. The tastes and traditions follow the men of Hesse, Wurttemberg, and Prussia, wherever they go, and disappear only after several generations.

Finally, must I say it? Most Germans who come to America nowadays bring along a kind of hatred for the political regime of their Fatherland, a democratic sentiment less pure from traces of envy than that of older Americans. They have, sometimes, a background of latent socialism . . . In Missouri, the man who represents best, in Germans eyes, aristocracy and fortune – the objects of his dislike – is the slaveowner. This explains the instinct which leads these people, as a whole, to enlist under the flag of abolitionism, and now under the flag of the Union.

The German element played an important role in the election of Mr. Lincoln and now is at the basis of the extreme popularity and the political future of General Fremont. The numerous staff of General Fremont only includes one American. His chief of staff is Colonel Asboth, a Hungarian and friend of Kossuth who came to America with him. Fremont’s chief of the engineer corps is Bavarian and several aides come from the Rhineland.

If one were to judge the United States by the talk heard about Fremont’s St. Louis headquarters, one would easily believe that the heirs of Washington, Jefferson, Franklin and Jackson have become a people of selfish and cowardly nouveaux riches, whose only social mission is to pay the brave children of the German fatherland to defend them, their institutions – of which they are unworthy – and the great principles of freedom.”

(Prince Napoleon in America, 1861. Camille Ferri Pisani, Indiana University Press, 1959, pp. 250-252)

 

Published by

Circa1865

This is an informational website created and maintained by North Carolina historian and author John Bernhard Thuersam. Born and reared in New York, he a graduate of Villa Maria College at Buffalo, the SUNY Buffalo, and graduate school at the University of Georgia. His 2022 book, "Rather Unsafe for a Southern Man to Live Here: Key West's Civil War was published by Shotwell Press; his 2022 book "Plymouth's Civil War: The Destruction of a North Carolina Town" was published in 2024 by Scuppernong Press. For the latter, Mr. Thuersam was awarded the 2025 "Douglas Southall Freeman Award" from the Military Order of the Stars & Bars.