Prince Napoleon’s Views in 1861

Prince Napoleon, nephew of Bonaparte, visited the US during July and August 1861 as the Civil War was beginning. On his trek westward he noted the deep effect German immigration was having in Missouri.

Prince Napoleon’s Views in 1861

“The predominance of the German element in the Army of the West is the result of the nature of the sources which fed the recruitment of volunteers. Many causes forced the Germans to serve the flag. First, the high pay of soldiers, an almost irresistible attraction for wretched emigrants who left their country because of their misfortune, and who, if they found bread in their new motherland, were nonetheless forced to earn it daily with their sweat. Moreover, Germany is the traditional land of professional soldiers. Germans embraced the military profession willingly, and not so long ago, they served as mercenaries in many of the world’s armies. The tastes and traditions follow the men of Hesse, Wurttemberg, and Prussia, wherever they go, and disappear only after several generations.

Finally, must I say it? Most Germans who come to America nowadays bring along a kind of hatred for the political regime of their Fatherland, a democratic sentiment less pure from traces of envy than that of older Americans. They have, sometimes, a background of latent socialism . . . In Missouri, the man who represents best, in Germans eyes, aristocracy and fortune – the objects of his dislike – is the slaveowner. This explains the instinct which leads these people, as a whole, to enlist under the flag of abolitionism, and now under the flag of the Union.

The German element played an important role in the election of Mr. Lincoln and now is at the basis of the extreme popularity and the political future of General Fremont. The numerous staff of General Fremont only includes one American. His chief of staff is Colonel Asboth, a Hungarian and friend of Kossuth who came to America with him. Fremont’s chief of the engineer corps is Bavarian and several aides come from the Rhineland.

If one were to judge the United States by the talk heard about Fremont’s St. Louis headquarters, one would easily believe that the heirs of Washington, Jefferson, Franklin and Jackson have become a people of selfish and cowardly nouveaux riches, whose only social mission is to pay the brave children of the German fatherland to defend them, their institutions – of which they are unworthy – and the great principles of freedom.”

(Prince Napoleon in America, 1861. Camille Ferri Pisani, Indiana University Press, 1959, pp. 250-252)

 

Fremont Takes the Lead

Fremont Takes the Lead

“General Fremont was the unruly child of the Republican party, or rather he had the nerve and audacity to compromise and embarrass those colleagues whom he does not like while ensuring his own political future. Convinced that sooner or later the abolitionist idea must triumph in the Union and that the possibility of compromise with the South is nothing but a dream – a dream that the present war must have dissipated – he moved ahead. By expressing what the clever ones have thus far not dared to admit, by taking the lead in a movement which will soon carry everyone with it, he gained for himself a position higher than all the men he had outrun.

A few days before our arrival in St. Louis, he issued a proclamation ordering, within the whole are of his command, the confiscation of property and immediate freedom of all slaves belonging to citizens who had declared themselves against the Union. You notice the very important shade of meaning.

What is serious, is not the confiscation of people’s properties, although for us administrative and military confiscation is a monstrosity; the capital point is the distinction established in the General’s decree between the property represented by the slave, and the property established by a house or plantation. That the slave be confiscated is so much the better!

Thus, he can be sold for the benefit of the Public Treasury, just as the house and the plantation will be auctioneered! But to free him is an innovation the importance of which escapes no one. This is to recognize that the abolition of slavery in the principal aim of the war, and to create between North and South an abyss that even piles of corpses will not suffice to fill.

We had more or less been told that the Army of the West was almost entirely composed of recently arrived emigrants, especially Germans. I must confess that I did not expect such a foreign character and practically isolates the army from the rest of the population. We were told that in St. Louis alone there were 30,000 inhabitants who, though American citizens, were born in Germany.

(Prince Napoleon in America, 1861. Camille Ferri Pisani, Indiana University Press, 1959, pp. 249-250)

 

Three Bavarian Brothers

Three Bavarian Brothers

In 1853, brothers Solomon, Marcus and Samuel Bear emigrated from Bavaria to Wilmington, North Carolina and soon immersed themselves in the growing German and Jewish population there.

Bavaria was the part of Germany where the largest number of Wilmington’s adult German immigrants hailed from by 1860. In contrast, German emigrants to Texas came mostly from the states of Hannover, Hesse and Nassau.

Wilmington’s German-Jewish immigrants were mostly self-employed merchants who most often began as clerks in Jewish-owned stores. In 1860, twelve of the eighteen clothing stores in town were Jewish-owned.  Business success followed Solomon Bear’s “Sol. Bear & Brothers” wholesale and retail clothing at 20 Market Street which included hats, boots, caps, fancy dry goods as well as wine and liquor.

An earlier Jewish immigrant to the city, Menasse Kahnweiler, involved himself in road construction, raising sheep, and real estate. In 1811 the upper floor of his building was a small synagogue for local Jews to worship. More German Jews arrived here and established such organizations as the Germania Lodge of the Knights of the Pythias, and the Schutzenverein Rifle, which evolved into the German Volunteers (German Light Infantry) led by Hanover-born Capt. Christian Cornehlson. That German immigrants in general were abolitionist-minded is inaccurate – the “48-er” socialist revolutionists who fled Germany after the abortive democratic uprisings of 1848 were in the abolitionist camp.

As was common in the American South in that era, Jewish merchants held black laborers with five at the Kahnweiler establishment in 1860 and owned by the company itself. Historian Jonathan Sarna tells us that “as a rule those Southern Jews who could afford slaves did so.” At the same time in Charlotte, North Carolina, three German-born, Jewish dry goods merchants owned slaves.

By 1858 Wilmington had developed a considerable German population which began a drive to build a place of worship in the city – soon to be known as St. Paul’s Lutheran when completed in that year with pastor Rev. John H. Mengert, D.D.  The German Jewish population also sought a place of worship, though not realized until after the war.

Solomon Bear was already involved with Wilmington’s German Volunteers when war came, which became Company A of the Eighteenth North Carolina Regiment on June 15, first serving as a hospital steward. Other German-born Hanoverians in the Volunteers were lieutenants Ackerman, Runge, Schulken and Vollers – and enlisted men with surnames such as Bachman, Henry Bear, Brahmer, Buckner, Dienstbach, Domler, Eigenbruner, Geier, Goldenschmidt, Gunther, Heins, Hoener, Jacoby, Katz, Klein, Koch, Koppel, Kordlander, Kornahreas, Kuhl, Kyhl, Linsbrink, Luhrs, Mauss, Ortman, Overbeck, Pfundt, Portwig, Rosenthal, Schlobohmm, Schoeber, Scwartz, Solomon, Steiniger, Stolter, Teller, Theis, Ulbrich, Von Glahn, Voss, Wagner, Weil and Westerman.  Jacob Blumenthal and Henry Wertheimer were among those who did not return home after the war.

As was common in the South, those with merchant and trading backgrounds were sent to Europe as purchasing agents for the Confederacy and Bear was no doubt charged with obtaining medical supplies to run through the blockade. The Kahnweiler store offered many European luxuries such as millinery, shoes and thread brought through the blockade. Nephew Simon Kahnweiler was a Southern agent in Europe and through his father in Philadelphia arranged for ships to run the blockade to Wilmington.

After the war Solomon returned home and became a driving force in the construction of the Temple of Isael at Fourth and Market Streets. A poignant photograph exists of the grey-clad veteran Solomon Bear on horseback on January 19, 1900 – Gen. Robert E. Lee’s Birthday.

(Jews at the Cape Fear Coast. Anton Heike, Southern Jewish History, 2010; Solomon Bear. Wilmington Past, Present and Future. 1883)

 

A Vast Empire of Slavery

The author below records that of the forced migration of Negroes from Africa to the Western Hemisphere, “about 9 to 10 million Africans were brought to the New World. Of these the thirteen British colonies, and later the United States, took only a small part – probably less than 400,000, surely not more than 500,000.”

A Vast Empire of Slavery

“Before [slavery as it existed in America] is examined, it is important to see hemispheric slavery as a whole. The growth of slavery in the English mainland colonies was only a small part of the immense world historic process in which over a span of three centuries African kings and chieftains, Portuguese, Spanish, Genoese, English, French, Dutch and Danish slave traders, Yankee merchants from England’s northern colonies, Portuguese, Spanish, English, Dutch and French planters in Latin America and the Caribbean islands, and the planters of the rice and tobacco colonies of the North American continent were all knit together in a far-flung fraternity of the unfraternal, engaged in the business of creating, supplying and exploiting a vast empire of slavery in the New World.

The North American colonies were only on the fringes of the immense South Atlantic system of slave trading and slave exploitation, which was mainly an affair of Central and South America and the sugar islands of the Caribbean. The precise dimensions of the slave trade are unknown, but the most educated guess, which has emerged from the impressive research of Philip Curtin, is that over the centuries of the slave trade territory of the United States received less than 5 percent of all the slaves brought to the Western Hemisphere.

The primary development of Negro slavery [after Africa itself] took place in tropical America, starting with Brazil in the late Sixteenth century and proceeding into the Caribbean where it reached its peak two hundred years later.”

(America at 1750: A Social Portrait. Richard Hofstadter. Vintage Books, 1973, pp. 67-68)

No Quarter Ordered

The 26th US Colored Troops regiment was formed in New York in February 1864 by the Union League Club of New York. This was one of three (USCT) regiments formed by that State and counted toward New York’s quota of troops required by Lincoln. Most if not all the colored men in the 26th Regiment were obtained in the South.

No Quarter Ordered

“On July 14, 1864, Gen. B.H. Robertson reported from John’s Island to the Confederate commander at Charleston, informing him that after a skirmish with the enemy, “Negro prisoners asserted that Col. William Silliman, commanding Twenty-sixth Regiment, US Colored Troops, in the presence of Brig-Gen. Rufus Saxton (who has always commanded Negroes), gave orders to show “no quarter.”

Gen. Robertson further said that Private Cooper, of Co. B., Second South Carolina Cavalry, had fallen into the hands of the enemy after being wounded; but that after the ground had been recovered and Cooper liberated, he was found bayoneted “in six or seven different places.”

(The South’s Burden- The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady, Nash Brothers, 1906, pg 86)

 

Prejudice of Color and Race

Prejudice of Color and Race

“In a letter written to Secretary of War Stanton Dec. 30, 1864, by Brig-Gen. Rufus Saxton, from Beaufort, South Carolina., In it he informs Stanton about to way in which Negroes were treated by those who were “saving the life of the nation.” I quote:

“Comparatively few of the Negroes are fit for soldiers; but Gen. [John G.] Foster [of New Hampshire] ordered an indiscriminate conscription of every able-bodied colored man in the department, which was an “apparent violation of the faith pledged to the freedmen.”

The order spread universal confusion and terror. The Negroes fled to the woods and swamps, visiting their cabins only by stealth and in darkness.” Also, “three boys, only fourteen years of age, were seized in a field where they were at work and sent to a regiment serving in a distant part of the department without the knowledge or consent of their parents.”

“I found the prejudice of color and race here in full force and the general feeling of the army of occupation was unfriendly to the blacks. It was manifested in various forms of personal insult and abuse, in depredations on their plantations – those taken from their owners and rented to the Negroes – stealing and destroying their crops and domestic animals, and robbing them of their money. The [colored] women were held as the legitimate prey of lust . . . there was a general disposition among [Northern] soldiers and civilian speculators here to defraud the Negroes in their private traffic, to take the commodities which they offered for sale by force, or to pay them with worthless money.”

(The South’s Burden- The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady, Nash Brothers, 1906, pp. 64-65)

Brownson’s Various Conversions

Vermont-born Orestes Brownson, 1803-1876, was initially raised Presbyterian but by age nineteen, like many New Englanders, was immersed in “a speckled crowd of sectaries, Universalists, deists, atheists, “nothingarians,” as they were called, as well as those professing no particular form of religion. By 1824 he became a Universalist though soon afterward declared it a “false theology” – then was drawn to Unitarianism.

Brownson’s Various Conversions

“On August 3, 1836, the Anti-Slavery Society of Boston attempted to celebrate the anniversary of the emancipation of British West Indies Island slaves, a mob gathered around the building where the Society was to assemble, which forced the landlord to bar the entrance. The Society repaired to a private residence to hear Brownson deliver a prayer, and the Society dispersed afterward. It was reported that the “mob” which had interfered was made up mainly of very respectable Southern gentlemen and Boston merchants.

It was the Great Depression of 1837 which brought Brownson for the first time into practical politics . . . [he thought brought on] by the wickedness of the banks, in refusing to pay their debts, and the moral obtuseness of the community which could tolerate, nay defend, in these moneyed corporations, conduct which would have been severely punished in the case of private individuals. [He now felt] compelled to align himself more closely with the Democratic party. For him, Jacksonian democracy had neither been sufficiently radical nor earnest in carrying out the true principles of what he called social democracy. But with the extra session of Congress then called by President Van Buren, he thought he saw the Democratic party on the eve of adopting, on the one hand, the States’ rights doctrines of the South – to which he had become a convert by the famous Senate debate between Webster and Hayne – and of accepting, on the other hand, the Locofoco doctrines of equal rights for all with a corresponding campaign against all privileges and monopolies of banks and banking, and other corporations.

Brownson came to understand the dangers of democracy in the United States, as did John C. Calhoun. He wrote: “[But] when the Federal Government has succeeded in getting under its control, directly or indirectly, nearly all the internal affairs of the States, and is able to make its act, like the frogs of Egypt, reach our domestic hearths, and to come up in our sleeping chambers and kneading troughs, we may be assured that the first barriers to a consolidated despotism have been leaped.”

(Orestes A. Brownson. A Definite Biography. Thomas Ryan. Our Sunday Visitor, Inc. 1976, pp. 114; 119-120, 131)

New England History

In May of 1637 the Puritan militia attacked a Pequot community near today’s Mystic, Connecticut, killing many and pursuing the remaining men, women, and children across southern New England. The Pequot men captured were killed, with women and children enslaved as spoils of war. Others were shipped to the Caribbean islands and worked to death on sugar cane fields.

New England History

“To the modern reader who has accepted the sectional misrepresentations of the last half-century as historical verities a comparison of the Northerner with the Southerner will be unsatisfactory unless it locates the responsibility for African slavery in the United States, since that has been regarded as the Pandora’s box which was opened when the thirteen States entered into a federal compact.

Hence, omitting references to the South’s well-known responsibilities in the premises, I present here the evidence on which a fair decision can be based:

  1. In 1638 the Salem slave ship, the Desire, brought into Massachusetts a number of Negroes, and found ready sale for them. This “was not a private individual speculation,” says Moore (Notes on the History of Slavery in Massachusetts); “it was the enterprise of the authorities on the colony.”
  2. In 1639 an African queen had been brought across the waters and sold to “Mr. Maverick,” as we are informed in Joselyn’s Account of Two Voyages to New England; and Mr. Maverick undertook to compel her to raise him an improved breed of slaves. “This she took in high disdain beyond her slavery.”
  3. In 1643 the Colonies of Massachusetts Bay, Plymouth, Connecticut and New Haven formed a Confederation, agreeing among other stipulations to mutually surrender fugitive slaves.
  4. In 1641, say Hildreth, “Massachusetts adopted her Body of Liberties, which “recognized and authorized the slavery of such strangers as are sold to us.”
  5. 1676 was the year when Wappanoag Sachem Massasoit’s nine-year-old grandson was shipped to Bermuda and sold as a slave.
  6. In 1796 John Dorsey advertised two runaway slaves in Young and Mims Boston Mercury, stating that the reward offered for their capture and return to him should include “what the law allows.” This was sixteen years after the “powerful civilization” of Massachusetts, as was arrogantly asserted by Senator Sumner in his debate with Senator Butler of South Carolina, in June, 1854, had “exterminated every vestige of slavery within her borders.”

 

But African slaves proved to be unprofitable in the Northern States . . . and the boasted superior humanity of that section is disproved by the fact that much of the shipping of the Northern States was employed in the slave trade from 1638 to 1862. In 1861 the ship Nightingale, of Boston, commanded by Francis Bowen, was captured on the African coast with 951 Negroes on board and “expecting more.”

(The South’s Burden: The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady. Nash Brothers, 1906, pp. 19-20)

The Corruption of Land

The term “cronyism” appears several times in the American political scene and after the independence of the American South in 1861 the new Republican party ramped it up. Absent Southern State opposition in Congress:

“northern Republicans possessed sufficient power to force through domestic planks of the American System: transcontinental land grants, protectionist tariffs to benefit Northern industries, and quasi-central-banking regulations. These special favors were the building blocks for a government structure of widespread restrictions and subsidies, and they were up for sale to the interest groups willing to fight for them.”

The Corruption of Land

“The fate of the infant United States initially hinged on the battle between free-market Jeffersonian Republicans and interventionist Hamiltonian Federalists. After Thomas Jefferson won the presidency in 1800 and rolled back the judicial bureaucracy, taxes and military expenditures, his desire to establish a limited confederation ran aground on the tantalizing opportunity to purchase France’s Louisiana Territory. Jefferson, though recognizing that the acquisition conflicted with his constitutional scruples, could not refuse five hundred million acres.

He then embarked upon his own brand of favoritism to keep the swollen empire from breaking apart, including payments to land speculators, centralization of internal, improvements, tariffs and mercantile protection, and plans to conquer Canada and Florida. By the War of 1812, Jefferson’s Republicans were indistinguishable from the Federalists they previously fought.

An “Era of Corruption” ensued in the following decade as the new National Republicans devised an American System of central banking, [tariff] protectionism, public works largesse, federal abrogation of settlers’ rights, and foreign aggression. By 1825 the situation had gotten so deplorable that Secretary of State John Quincy Adams and Speaker of the House Henry Clay bribed congressmen in an overtime House election to steal the presidency from the frontrunner, Senator Andrew Jackson, and give it to Adams.

In the face of such flagrant corruption, Jackson allied with the politico Martin Van Buren to create a new Democratic Party devoted to restoring the old Jeffersonian laissez-faire ideology to counter the National Republicans’ growing cronyism.

The Jacksonian Democrats’ free-market reforms reduced government barriers to entry and other economic interventions. This enabled businesses to better allocate the country’s domestic pool of workers, new waves of immigrants, abundant natural resources, and growing levels of savings toward producing goods that consumers valued. Relatively freer competition in banking led to safer and more efficient banks compared to federal and State chartered monopolies. The new institutional groundwork for a new Industrial Revolution had been laid.”

(Cronyism: The Rise of the Corporatist State: 1849-1929. Patrick Newman. Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2026, pp. 31-32; 56)

 

Prewar Immigration Fears

Orestes Brownson, 1803-1876, was born in Vermont, raised Calvinist and later Catholic convert. As an antebellum political activist, he saw the two-great political parties, Whig and Democrat as nearly equally balanced in most regions of the country. But he also saw immigration as introducing both parties to bidding for the “foreign vote,” which he saw as truly ruling the country.

Prewar Immigration Fears

“[Brownson] explained that from the years 1820-1845 the flow of immigration into the country had been principally Catholic, and hence sufficiently conservative in nature to exert a wholesome moral and religious influence on the country. But since 1845, and especially since 1849, the character of the immigration has been entirely different.

The reaction to the revolutionary movement on the continent of Europe that began in 1849 had poured a still larger immigration onto our shores in which an infidel and anarchical element predominated, and which currently seemed likely to predominate.

He confessed that he was opposed, not to the coming of such to our shores, but rather to their ready admission into the bosom of American political society. He feared that the support such an element would bring into the filibustering, ultra-democratic fanatical tendencies of some of his countrymen would only tend to undermine genuine republicanism as it was conceived in the minds of the Founding Fathers.

He simply did not believe that such immigrants were entitled to political citizenship since they were “to a fearful extent banded together in secret societies, affiliated to the terrible secret societies of Europe, and directed by foreign demagogues and revolutionists, such as Kossuth and Mazzini.” Such immigrants showed no intention of becoming quiet, orderly and loyal American citizens. Hence, Brownson concluded:

“As an American citizen and as an American republican, we cannot but be opposed to their naturalization, and a fortiori as a Catholic; for they are the worst enemies of the Church in this country, are hand and glove with the [anti-immigrant] Know-Nothings taken generally and may be regarded as the real instigators and the most effective supporters of the Know-Nothing movement. Know-Nothingism is no Yankee invention, no American production, but a combination of Irish Orangeism, German radicalism, French socialism, and Italian astuteness and hate.”

In speaking of “Italian astuteness and hate,” Brownson was of course referring particularly to the notorious apostate priest Alessandro Gavazzi, who with the dregs of Italian and German revolutionists fomented the “Bendini Riots” through the country on the occasion of the visit of Archbishop Bendini to the United States in 1853. When, on this tour, he reached Cincinnati, an organized attempt was made to hang him and destroy the cathedral there.

Brownson emphasized that American citizenship is a boon or a grant, not a natural or indefeasible right. As it is the right of every sovereign society to open or close to whom it will, so it is the right of every nation to close its political citizenship, if it sees proper, to all foreign-born immigrants that might prove a danger, or that it would bring no advantage to it.”

(Orestes A. Brownson. A Definite Biography. Thomas Ryan. Our Sunday Visitor, Inc. 1976, pp. 470-471)