No Quarter Ordered

The 26th US Colored Troops regiment was formed in New York in February 1864 by the Union League Club of New York. This was one of three (USCT) regiments formed by that State and counted toward New York’s quota of troops required by Lincoln. Most if not all the colored men in the 26th Regiment were obtained in the South.

No Quarter Ordered

“On July 14, 1864, Gen. B.H. Robertson reported from John’s Island to the Confederate commander at Charleston, informing him that after a skirmish with the enemy, “Negro prisoners asserted that Col. William Silliman, commanding Twenty-sixth Regiment, US Colored Troops, in the presence of Brig-Gen. Rufus Saxton (who has always commanded Negroes), gave orders to show “no quarter.”

Gen. Robertson further said that Private Cooper, of Co. B., Second South Carolina Cavalry, had fallen into the hands of the enemy after being wounded; but that after the ground had been recovered and Cooper liberated, he was found bayoneted “in six or seven different places.”

(The South’s Burden- The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady, Nash Brothers, 1906, pg 86)

 

Prejudice of Color and Race

Prejudice of Color and Race

“In a letter written to Secretary of War Stanton Dec. 30, 1864, by Brig-Gen. Rufus Saxton, from Beaufort, South Carolina., In it he informs Stanton about to way in which Negroes were treated by those who were “saving the life of the nation.” I quote:

“Comparatively few of the Negroes are fit for soldiers; but Gen. [John G.] Foster [of New Hampshire] ordered an indiscriminate conscription of every able-bodied colored man in the department, which was an “apparent violation of the faith pledged to the freedmen.”

The order spread universal confusion and terror. The Negroes fled to the woods and swamps, visiting their cabins only by stealth and in darkness.” Also, “three boys, only fourteen years of age, were seized in a field where they were at work and sent to a regiment serving in a distant part of the department without the knowledge or consent of their parents.”

“I found the prejudice of color and race here in full force and the general feeling of the army of occupation was unfriendly to the blacks. It was manifested in various forms of personal insult and abuse, in depredations on their plantations – those taken from their owners and rented to the Negroes – stealing and destroying their crops and domestic animals, and robbing them of their money. The [colored] women were held as the legitimate prey of lust . . . there was a general disposition among [Northern] soldiers and civilian speculators here to defraud the Negroes in their private traffic, to take the commodities which they offered for sale by force, or to pay them with worthless money.”

(The South’s Burden- The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady, Nash Brothers, 1906, pp. 64-65)

Brownson’s Various Conversions

Vermont-born Orestes Brownson, 1803-1876, was initially raised Presbyterian but by age nineteen, like many New Englanders, was immersed in “a speckled crowd of sectaries, Universalists, deists, atheists, “nothingarians,” as they were called, as well as those professing no particular form of religion. By 1824 he became a Universalist though soon afterward declared it a “false theology” – then was drawn to Unitarianism.

Brownson’s Various Conversions

“On August 3, 1836, the Anti-Slavery Society of Boston attempted to celebrate the anniversary of the emancipation of British West Indies Island slaves, a mob gathered around the building where the Society was to assemble, which forced the landlord to bar the entrance. The Society repaired to a private residence to hear Brownson deliver a prayer, and the Society dispersed afterward. It was reported that the “mob” which had interfered was made up mainly of very respectable Southern gentlemen and Boston merchants.

It was the Great Depression of 1837 which brought Brownson for the first time into practical politics . . . [he thought brought on] by the wickedness of the banks, in refusing to pay their debts, and the moral obtuseness of the community which could tolerate, nay defend, in these moneyed corporations, conduct which would have been severely punished in the case of private individuals. [He now felt] compelled to align himself more closely with the Democratic party. For him, Jacksonian democracy had neither been sufficiently radical nor earnest in carrying out the true principles of what he called social democracy. But with the extra session of Congress then called by President Van Buren, he thought he saw the Democratic party on the eve of adopting, on the one hand, the States’ rights doctrines of the South – to which he had become a convert by the famous Senate debate between Webster and Hayne – and of accepting, on the other hand, the Locofoco doctrines of equal rights for all with a corresponding campaign against all privileges and monopolies of banks and banking, and other corporations.

Brownson came to understand the dangers of democracy in the United States, as did John C. Calhoun. He wrote: “[But] when the Federal Government has succeeded in getting under its control, directly or indirectly, nearly all the internal affairs of the States, and is able to make its act, like the frogs of Egypt, reach our domestic hearths, and to come up in our sleeping chambers and kneading troughs, we may be assured that the first barriers to a consolidated despotism have been leaped.”

(Orestes A. Brownson. A Definite Biography. Thomas Ryan. Our Sunday Visitor, Inc. 1976, pp. 114; 119-120, 131)

New England History

In May of 1637 the Puritan militia attacked a Pequot community near today’s Mystic, Connecticut, killing many and pursuing the remaining men, women, and children across southern New England. The Pequot men captured were killed, with women and children enslaved as spoils of war. Others were shipped to the Caribbean islands and worked to death on sugar cane fields.

New England History

“To the modern reader who has accepted the sectional misrepresentations of the last half-century as historical verities a comparison of the Northerner with the Southerner will be unsatisfactory unless it locates the responsibility for African slavery in the United States, since that has been regarded as the Pandora’s box which was opened when the thirteen States entered into a federal compact.

Hence, omitting references to the South’s well-known responsibilities in the premises, I present here the evidence on which a fair decision can be based:

  1. In 1638 the Salem slave ship, the Desire, brought into Massachusetts a number of Negroes, and found ready sale for them. This “was not a private individual speculation,” says Moore (Notes on the History of Slavery in Massachusetts); “it was the enterprise of the authorities on the colony.”
  2. In 1639 an African queen had been brought across the waters and sold to “Mr. Maverick,” as we are informed in Joselyn’s Account of Two Voyages to New England; and Mr. Maverick undertook to compel her to raise him an improved breed of slaves. “This she took in high disdain beyond her slavery.”
  3. In 1643 the Colonies of Massachusetts Bay, Plymouth, Connecticut and New Haven formed a Confederation, agreeing among other stipulations to mutually surrender fugitive slaves.
  4. In 1641, say Hildreth, “Massachusetts adopted her Body of Liberties, which “recognized and authorized the slavery of such strangers as are sold to us.”
  5. 1676 was the year when Wappanoag Sachem Massasoit’s nine-year-old grandson was shipped to Bermuda and sold as a slave.
  6. In 1796 John Dorsey advertised two runaway slaves in Young and Mims Boston Mercury, stating that the reward offered for their capture and return to him should include “what the law allows.” This was sixteen years after the “powerful civilization” of Massachusetts, as was arrogantly asserted by Senator Sumner in his debate with Senator Butler of South Carolina, in June, 1854, had “exterminated every vestige of slavery within her borders.”

 

But African slaves proved to be unprofitable in the Northern States . . . and the boasted superior humanity of that section is disproved by the fact that much of the shipping of the Northern States was employed in the slave trade from 1638 to 1862. In 1861 the ship Nightingale, of Boston, commanded by Francis Bowen, was captured on the African coast with 951 Negroes on board and “expecting more.”

(The South’s Burden: The Curse of Sectionalism in the United States. Benjamin Franklin Grady. Nash Brothers, 1906, pp. 19-20)

Prewar Immigration Fears

Orestes Brownson, 1803-1876, was born in Vermont, raised Calvinist and later Catholic convert. As an antebellum political activist, he saw the two-great political parties, Whig and Democrat as nearly equally balanced in most regions of the country. But he also saw immigration as introducing both parties to bidding for the “foreign vote,” which he saw as truly ruling the country.

Prewar Immigration Fears

“[Brownson] explained that from the years 1820-1845 the flow of immigration into the country had been principally Catholic, and hence sufficiently conservative in nature to exert a wholesome moral and religious influence on the country. But since 1845, and especially since 1849, the character of the immigration has been entirely different.

The reaction to the revolutionary movement on the continent of Europe that began in 1849 had poured a still larger immigration onto our shores in which an infidel and anarchical element predominated, and which currently seemed likely to predominate.

He confessed that he was opposed, not to the coming of such to our shores, but rather to their ready admission into the bosom of American political society. He feared that the support such an element would bring into the filibustering, ultra-democratic fanatical tendencies of some of his countrymen would only tend to undermine genuine republicanism as it was conceived in the minds of the Founding Fathers.

He simply did not believe that such immigrants were entitled to political citizenship since they were “to a fearful extent banded together in secret societies, affiliated to the terrible secret societies of Europe, and directed by foreign demagogues and revolutionists, such as Kossuth and Mazzini.” Such immigrants showed no intention of becoming quiet, orderly and loyal American citizens. Hence, Brownson concluded:

“As an American citizen and as an American republican, we cannot but be opposed to their naturalization, and a fortiori as a Catholic; for they are the worst enemies of the Church in this country, are hand and glove with the [anti-immigrant] Know-Nothings taken generally and may be regarded as the real instigators and the most effective supporters of the Know-Nothing movement. Know-Nothingism is no Yankee invention, no American production, but a combination of Irish Orangeism, German radicalism, French socialism, and Italian astuteness and hate.”

In speaking of “Italian astuteness and hate,” Brownson was of course referring particularly to the notorious apostate priest Alessandro Gavazzi, who with the dregs of Italian and German revolutionists fomented the “Bendini Riots” through the country on the occasion of the visit of Archbishop Bendini to the United States in 1853. When, on this tour, he reached Cincinnati, an organized attempt was made to hang him and destroy the cathedral there.

Brownson emphasized that American citizenship is a boon or a grant, not a natural or indefeasible right. As it is the right of every sovereign society to open or close to whom it will, so it is the right of every nation to close its political citizenship, if it sees proper, to all foreign-born immigrants that might prove a danger, or that it would bring no advantage to it.”

(Orestes A. Brownson. A Definite Biography. Thomas Ryan. Our Sunday Visitor, Inc. 1976, pp. 470-471)

 

Vast New Merchandising Opportunities

Jim Fisk’s father, known as “Pop,” was pure Yankee descended from English forbears, an itinerant peddler who left home with a loaded wagon on Mondays to return at week’s end with diminished cargo but thicker wallet. On one peddling trip, he ran out of shawls and had an excess of small, flowered tablecloths, he assured housewives that the tablecloths were the latest Boston style in shawls and sold them all.”

Below, Fisk’s son Jim followed in his father’s footsteps, doing what it took to turn a profit. Once war came, he never “felt any desire to shoulder a musket and help save the Union,” leaving the war to be fought by enthusiastic volunteers and reluctant draftees, and himself more like those who bought their way out.

During the war Jim hired adventurous actress Lottie Hough to wheedle passes through Union lines and her success so complete that she retired postwar with an immense fortune. As Grant closed in on Richmond and sensing the Confederacy’s inevitable demise, he and a small clique sent an agent to London to buy Confederate bonds short to all buyers. The agent arrived two days before news of Lee’s surrender reached England, after making a financial killing for his employers.

The Jordan Marsh enterprise below was founded at Boston in 1841 by Eben Dyer Jordan and Benjamin L. Marsh.

Vast New Merchandising Opportunities

“Unlike most Bostonians, Fisk sensed that the South would not swallow Lincoln, that a war was coming. In the merits of the North-South quarrel he took little interest, but it struck him that whatever they were fighting about would open vast new merchandising opportunities. When Sumter fell and the war did come, he went to Washington to see if the government might be interested in purchasing textiles.

No one entertained with the rollicking bonhomie of James Fisk, Jr., one of the first of the war profiteers. Fisk’s company had several thousand blankets of an unappetizing color and somewhat mildewed. Retailers spurned them but Uncle Sam snapped them up.

In 1862, with cotton rotting in Southern warehouses and hard to come by in the North even at two dollars a pound, he set about to remedy the imbalance. While getting cotton out of the South involved trading with the enemy, violating the blockade, smuggling and possibly other illegalities, he justified on the ground of patriotism, reasoning that it was ridiculous that soldiers should be deprived of essential clothing – and merchants of profit – because of a mere technicality. The details of this bootleg operation, with its essential stratagems and bribes, remain dim, for he said little about it after the war.

Fisk never lacked courage if there was money in it, made several buying trips into the Dixie No Man’s Land . . . sending cotton north by the boatload, cargoes of fabulous value that kept the spindles whirring at Jordan Marsh, now the nation’s biggest enterprise of its kind. One of his biographers solemnly avers that his purchases of contraband cotton reached peaks as high as $800,000 a day.”

(Jim Fisk: The Career of an Unstoppable Rascal. W.A. Swanberg. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1959, pp. 17-19

Shapers of Opinion

Those around Lincoln in mid-1864 were unsure of his reelection as emancipation was far from being popular, Grant’s casualty lists were endless and heartbreaking, and the draft was universally hated. Even Lincoln believed he would be replaced. To the rescue came   insiders like Assistant Secretary of War Charles A. Dana, the former editor of Horace Greeley’s New York Tribune. Dana wrote: “All the power and influence of the War Department was employed to secure the re-election of Mr. Lincoln.” Some 200,000 soldiers were furloughed to go home and vote, as well as patrol the polls to ensure Republican ballots were being cast. (Prince of Carpetbaggers, Jonathan Daniels. JB Lippincott Co., 1958, p. 105)

Shapers of Opinion

“Dana’s Chicago Republican, as the name implied, was strictly partisan, as was nearly every other contemporary newspaper. If the truth be told, editors of that era generally saw their job as more of shaping of opinion than the providing of news. And if they had to stretch the truth to get results? Well, that came with the territory.

From the hour I first occupied the position of editor to the present time,” a retiring journalist confessed, I have been solicited to lie on every given subject, and can’t remember ever having told a wholesome truth without diminishing the subscription list or making an enemy . . . Having a thorough contempt for myself, I retire in order to recruit my moral constitution.”

Except for subscribers to large metropolitan dailies, Americans interested in politics got their news from the partisan press and that press depended on party coffers and official funding. Editors acquired tremendous power, and far too often politicians awarded contracts and patronage because of that power. They also listened if an editor recommended someone for office, especially if that someone was the editor himself.”

(The General and the Journalists: Grant, Greeley and Dana. Harry Maihafer. Brassey’s Inc., 1998, p. 87; 222)

 

Crafty Draft Dodger

The letter below was sent to Mary’s brother-in-law, Corporal Josiah H. Sturtevant of the 17th Maine Regiment, who was offered an officer’s commission in the 80th US Colored Troops regiment in March 1863. As few white officers would accept service in a colored regiment, an effective strategy was to offer a white enlisted men receiving $15 per month a pay increase to $105 as a second lieutenant. Ironically, Sturtevant continued receiving enlisted pay while incurring the expenses of an officer through the end of the war and not receiving restitution until 25 years after the war.

The letter also refers to the $300 commutation which bought a substitute for conscripted Northern men – and reveals the great interest in colored troops serving in place of white Northern citizens who wished to remain at home.

Mount Vernon, N.Y., January 3, 1864

Dear Brother Josiah:

“Mr. Lee, the patriotic Dutch Reformed Minister, was drafted. He has always said if he was drafted, he should certainly go. After he was drafted, he said: “The Lord had given him a loud call to go, and if he didn’t give him a louder one to stay at home, he should go. He whined and griped around till he begged $300 to pay his commutation.

What did he do but pay $100 for a Town bond that draws 10% interest, cooly pockets the other $200, and at the end of the year gets the other $100 and so the $300 eventually comes out of the town taxpayers.

Now I say such a rascal ought to be roasted over a slow fire, at least till the war is over, and I would willingly gather faggots to keep it burning till my arms were worn off my shoulders.

I have always contended that the African, give him an equal chance, will make as good if not better soldiers than his white brother, and I believe we shall see the day that nine-tenths of our standing army will be composed of the freed men of the Nation.

Yours,

Mary”

(Josiah Volunteered. A Collection of Diaries and Letters. Arnold H. Sturtevant. 1977, pp. 114; 115)

A Distinguishing Mark of Gentle Nurture

A Distinguishing Mark of Gentle Nurture

“Of course, what was to all true Confederates beyond a question a “holy cause,” “the holiest of causes,” this fight in defence of “the sacred soil” of our native land, was to the other side “a wicked rebellion” and “damnable treason,” and both parties to the quarrel were not sparing of epithets which, at the distance of time, may seem to our children unnecessarily undignified; and not doubt some of these epitheta orantia continue to flourish in remote regions, just a pictorial representations of Yankees and rebels in all their respective fiendishness are still cherished here and there.

At the Centennial Exposition of 1876, by way of conciliating the sections, the place of honor in the “Art Annex” was given to Rothermel’s painting of the battle of Gettysburg, in which the face of every dying Union soldier is lighted with a celestial smile, while guilt and despair are stamped on the wan countenances of the moribund rebels. At least such is my recollection of the painting; and I hope that I may be pardoned for the malicious pleasure I felt when informed of the high price the State of Pennsylvania paid for that work of art. The dominant feeling was amusement, not indignation.

But as I looked at it, I recalled another picture of a battle-scene, painted by a French artist, who had watched our life with an artist’s eye. One of the figures in the foreground was a dead Confederate boy, lying in the angle of a worm fence. His uniform was worn and ragged, mud-stained as well as blood-stained; the cap which had fallen from his head was a tatter, and the torn shoes were ready to drop from his stiffening feet; but in the buttonhole of his tunic was stuck the inevitable toothbrush, which continued even to the end of the war to be the distinguishing mark of gentle nurture – the souvenir that the Confederate soldier so often received from fair sympathizers in border towns.

I am not a realist, but I would not exchange that homely toothbrush for the most angelic smile that Rothermel’s brush could have conjured up.”

(The Creed of the Old South. Basil L. Gildersleeve. The Johns Hopkins Press, 1915, pp. 17-19)

Northern Recruiters in Canada

In late 1863, Lt. John Wilkinson of the famed blockade runner Robert E. Lee was ordered to Halifax, Nova Scotia, then Montreal and Lake Erie on a mission to overwhelm the crew of the USS Michigan guarding the infamous Johnson’s Island prison. He and his small force planned to free the 2500 Southern officers held there.

Northern Recruiters in Canada

“I had been furnished, before leaving Richmond, with letters to parties in Canada, who, it was believed, could give valuable aid to the expedition. To expedite matters, a trustworthy agent and canny Scotsman who had long served under my command, was dispatched to Montreal, via Portland [Ontario], to notify these parties that we were on our way there. Our emissary, taking passage on a steamer bound for Portland, passed safely through United States territory, while the rest of us commenced our long and devious route through the British Provinces [of Canada].

Wherever we travelled, even through the remotest settlements, recruiting agents for the United States army were at work, scarcely affecting to disguise their occupation; and the walls of the obscurest country taverns bristled with advertisements like the following:

‘Wanted for a tannery in Maine, 1000 men to whom a large bonus will be paid, etc.”

Many could not resist the allurements, but it was from this class of and similar ones, no doubt, that the “bounty jumpers” sprang. It has been asserted, by those who were in a position to form a correct estimate, that the British Provinces alone, contributed one hundred thousand men to the Federal army.”

(The Narrative of a Blockade-Runner. John Wilkinson. Valde Books, 2009 (original Sheldon & Company, 1877), pp. 72-73)