Aftermath: Despotism, America Transformed, Crimes of War, Enemies of the Republic, Hatred of the American South, Historians on History, Lincoln Revealed, Lincoln's Revolutionary Legacy, Looting the Conquered, Lost Cultures, Myth of Saving the Union, New England History, No Compromise, Northern Culture Laid Bare, Pathways to Central Planning, Sherman's Legacy, Withdrawing from the Union 
Comments Off on Suppressing the Consent of the Governed Suppressing the Consent of the Governed
As asserted below, Americans in general seem unaware of the enormity of the Southern experience 1861-1865 and the aftermath of devastating defeat and subjugation. The author’s analogy brings needed perspective to an unnecessary war and death of a million Americans, counting military and civilian casualties.
Bernhard Thuersam, www.Circa1865.com
Suppressing the Consent of the Governed
“Imagine America invaded by a foreign power, one that has quadruple the population and industrial base. Imagine that this enemy has free access to the world’s goods as well as an inexhaustible supply of cannon fodder from the proletariat of other countries, while America itself is tightly blockaded from the outside world.
New York and Cincinnati have been taken. For months, Boston and Chicago have been under constant siege, the civilian population driven from their homes. Enemy forces roam over large parts of the country burning the homes, tools and food of the noncombatants in a campaign of deliberate terrorism.
Nearly eighty-five percent of the nation’s able-bodied men (up to 50 years of age) have been called to arms. Battlefield casualties have run to 39 percent and deaths amount to half of that, far exceeding those from any other war.
On the other hand, the enemy, though its acts and domestic propaganda indicate otherwise, is telling the American population that it only wants peace and the restoration of the status quo antebellum. Lay down your arms and all will be as before. What would be our state of morale in such conditions? Americans have never suffered such misfortune, have they?
Alas, they have. This was the experience of the Southern people from 1861-1865 in their lost War for Independence.
How hard the Southerners struggled for independence from the American Empire has been, and continues to be, suppressed by a nationalist culture that can only wonder: How could any group possibly have dissented from the greatest government on earth? But a very large number of Americans did no consent that government (the regime, after all, was supposed to be founded on the consent of the governed).
They were willing to put their dissent on the line in a greater sacrifice than any large group of Americans has ever been called on to make. Until finally, as a disappointed Union officer quoted by [author Gary] Gallagher remarked: “The rebellion [was] worn out rather than suppressed.”
(An Honorable Defeat, Clyde Wilson, Chronicles, October 1998, pg. 28)